In a significant legal move, the global delivery corporation initiated legal proceedings against the US government on Monday, seeking to recover duties paid levied during Donald Trump's administration, which the US supreme court recently ruled were illegal.
A First Move in a Expected Flood of Lawsuits
This lawsuit represents the first attempt by a large company to get reimbursed for its portion of an approximate $175 billion in tariffs collected. The highest court found that the former president had exceeded his presidential powers in imposing the tariffs, leading to expectations that other businesses will likely follow suit.
The lawsuit lists the defendants as US Customs and Border Protection (CBP), the agency’s commissioner Rodney Scott, and the United States itself. Submitted to the US Court of International Trade, the company did not specify an exact amount but stated it is pursuing a “complete refund” for all duties paid.
“Although the supreme court did not address the issue of refunds, we have taken required steps to safeguard the company’s rights as an official importer to seek duty refunds from CBP,” the company stated.
Judicial Decision and Political Fallout
Tariffs had become central pillar of the former administration's trade strategy during his second term, applied to goods from nearly every country using a novel interpretation of emergency powers law as justification.
In a 6-3 ruling last Friday, the court made clear that Congress holds the exclusive power to impose taxes under the U.S. Constitution. It found that the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) cited by the Trump administration could not be used to supersede that congressional power during times of peace.
This decision represented the initial instance the Court has overruled policies from Trump's second term, weakening his claims to expansive presidential power. However, the court left unresolved whether businesses would be eligible for reimbursement.
In a dissenting opinion, Justice Kavanaugh commented on the reimbursement question, stating: “The court says nothing today about if, and if so how, the federal government should go about refunding the billions of dollars that it has collected from importers.” He added that “reimbursements of such large amounts would have major implications for the federal budget.”
Administration's Stance
Former President Trump quickly and harshly criticized the supreme court after the ruling, asserting it would not hinder his plans. He said he would move forward with new global tariffs based on different statutes, quickly announcing a worldwide ten percent duty which he later raised to 15% within less than 24 hours.
“The policy remains unchanged. The legal tools that enact it may change but the core strategy hasn’t changed,” a top US trade negotiator Jamieson Greer argued, saying it gives US business “significant negotiating power” in global commerce.
Political Pressure for Reimbursement
At the same time, a coalition of Democratic senators have called for reimbursements from the illegally collected tariffs to be directed toward small businesses. They have also pushed big corporations to redirect any funds received on to their customers.
According to an estimate from the a policy research group, the tariffs amounted to a $1,000 tax increase on American families in a recent year.
“Past data and recent studies show that import duties are forms of taxation that raise prices and limit the supply of products for US businesses and consumers,” the organization wrote, “leading to lower income, reduced employment, and diminished economic activity.”